What's in this template
One question and four example tools. Replace them with your shortlist, and consider adding an open-text question for the reasoning behind each vote.
Why tool decisions fail on adoption
The buyer isn't the user
Whoever runs the evaluation optimises for features and price. The team optimises for daily friction. A vote surfaces the gap before the contract, not six months in.
Objections arrive too late otherwise
People rarely volunteer 'I hate this tool' in a meeting where the decision looks made. An anonymous poll gets you the objection while it's still cheap to act on.
Adoption follows involvement
A tool the team chose gets used. A tool imposed on them gets worked around, and you pay for seats nobody opens.
Comments are the real output
The vote tells you which. The comments tell you why — and the why is usually what determines whether the rollout works.
Run it in three steps
Shortlist three or four tools
More than four and people vote on brand recognition rather than considered comparison.
Give people something to compare
Link to a trial or a short demo in the poll description, so the vote reflects use rather than reputation.
Read the comments first
Enable comments. The reasoning matters more than the count when you're about to commit budget.